Danny learns that a convict he wrongfully helped put in jail has escaped; Gormley criticizes an NYPD sergeant, who he believes is cheating with his wife.
Tim goes through a mid-life crisis, but instead of buying a hot car, he purchases a hot horse, forcing Amy to do some "dad whispering" to help him out.
Amy and Ty disagree over the risky investment Ty made when he purchased a barrel racing horse, and Amy's work with Prince Ahmed further complicates the matter.
Ted's brother Hal arrives in town and old sibling rivalries come back to life as Ted gets Mary to pretend she's his boyfriend for a double date with Rhoda.
After discovering that Howard will not be attending, Mary decides to attend her high school reunion with Rhoda by her side, but the event turns into a disaster.
Reba is amused to learn that Barbara Jean thinks her house is haunted, but finds it less amusing when she insists on a ceremony to rid her of the specter.
Kyra and Barbra Jean hide a stray cat in the attic to avoid setting off Brock's allergies, while Reba and Brock compete for Jake's affection with presents.
The Outdoor Man decides to produce a skit inspired by a classic western with Ed and Eve set to star, while Mandy turns her attention to an oblivious Kyle.
Mike hires a private soccer coach to train Eve for a college scholarship, but the ladies in the house become captivated with the young man who gets the job.
When two teens go missing, it's up to the entire team to find the girls and uncover the truth about their disappearance; Lopez and Harper search for a nanny.
Jamie is caught on camera engaging in what could be interpreted as police brutality; Danny and Baez examine a rape case concerning a civil rights attorney.
Danny and Baez hunt down the last remaining Mustang that Steve McQueen drove in "Bullitt"; officers are at risk of being arrested for fixing friends' tickets.