In an attempt to make Cheryl feel desired, Jim fakes a jealous rage over her between himself and a waiter; Jim teaches Dana's date how to fake jealousy.
Cory attempts to prove his manliness as an engaged man by going out with his male counterparts to a popular restaurant, where he loses his engagement ring.
Cory unknowingly ridicules his best friend's written work when Mr. Feeny gives Shawn indirect praise by reading his emotional poem aloud for the entire class.
By thinking he can become more popular, Eric creates a TV show similar to The Truman Show featuring his roommates, but it's Rachel who becomes popular.
Jim is jealous of Cheryl's yoga instructor, and decides to take class with her; they start taking classes behind each others' backs to escape home life.
Andy asks Jim for help in choosing a birthday present for Mandy, but when he attempts to follow Jim's advice, he ends up being accused of cheating on her.
Cheryl and her friends organize a play date for Jim, the other dads and the kids, and Jim makes the best of babysitting by turning it into a sporting event.
After inheriting six penguins, a career businessman begins to learn that there is more to life than his career, as he converts his home into a wonderland.
A young Colombian girl struggles to deal with being the only person in her family without magical powers, but their hidden, magic place soon becomes in danger.
Jamie Laing and Sophie Habboo navigate the rollercoaster of pregnancy, balancing their busy professional lives and moving into their first family home.
Jim grows a mustache that Cheryl hates because a hot delivery girl advised him to do so; Cheryl retaliates by becoming a brunette but Jim loves the change.